Best Seafood on the First Coast
Fish camps, shrimp shacks, and the two or three worth dressing up for.
11 places · Updated August 2026

Safe Harbor Seafood Restaurant
Seafood · Beaches · $$The boats unload a few hundred feet from the counter, which is as short as the supply chain gets anywhere in Northeast Florida.

Singletons Seafood Shack
Seafood · Beaches · $$Old-Florida fish shack that has resisted every impulse to modernize, and the shrimp is the order.

Palm Valley Fish Camp
Seafood · Ponte Vedra · $$The polished version of a fish camp, with Intracoastal seating and a kitchen that takes the cooking more seriously than the genre requires.

North Beach Fish Camp
Seafood · Beaches · $$Beaches-side fish camp with a tighter, more focused menu than most, and it's the one locals send other locals to.

Marker 32
Southern · Intracoastal · $$$The upscale end of the local seafood scene, on the water, and the one where the wine list is a real consideration.

The Fish Company
Seafood · Beaches · $$Market and restaurant in one, so you can eat there or take home what you didn't order.

Salt Life Food Shack
Seafood · Beaches · $$Beachfront, casual, and the rooftop makes it a better hangout than most oceanfront restaurants that coast on location.

O'Steen's Restaurant
Seafood · St. Augustine · $$Cash-friendly, no-reservations fried shrimp that people wait outside for, and it has been the regional benchmark for decades.

Cap's On the Water
Seafood · St. Augustine · $$Oak-shaded deck on the Intracoastal north of town, and it's worth the drive from Jacksonville specifically for the setting.

Catch 27
Seafood · St. Augustine · $$Small St. Augustine room focused on Florida-caught fish, and it's the counterpoint to the tourist seafood on St. George Street.

Blue Fish Restaurant and Oyster Bar
Seafood · Riverside/Avondale · $$The in-town option when you want good seafood without driving to the water.